Gold is taxed differently almost everywhere — and the differences can wipe out the diversification benefit if ignored. A practical comparison across three regimes.
Contents5 sections
Two investors holding identical gold positions can experience wildly different after-tax returns depending on jurisdiction. The tax treatment of bullion is one of the most overlooked aspects of allocation decisions, and the rules are unintuitive in every major Western system.
United States: the collectibles trap
The IRS classifies physical gold and most gold ETFs as collectibles, taxed at a maximum long-term capital gains rate of 28% rather than the 20% applied to equities. This applies to GLD, IAU and physical bars equally. Sprott's PHYS, structured as a trust with a Qualified Electing Fund election, can sometimes qualify for 20% LTCG treatment.
- Physical bullion: 28% LTCG max
- GLD/IAU: 28% LTCG (collectibles look-through)
- PHYS with QEF election: potentially 20%
- Mining stocks: standard 20% LTCG
- Gold IRAs: deferral with strict storage rules
United Kingdom: the legal tender advantage
UK investors receive a substantial benefit if they buy British Sovereigns or Britannias. These coins are legal tender and therefore exempt from capital gains tax, regardless of holding period or size. Foreign coins and bars are subject to standard CGT rates (currently 24% for higher-rate taxpayers above the annual exempt amount). VAT on investment gold was abolished in 2000.
"The CGT exemption on UK legal-tender gold coins is the single most generous tax treatment of any liquid investment in the British system." — UK private wealth advisor, quoted in FT 2024
European Union: VAT-free but country-specific
The EU treats investment gold as VAT-exempt across all member states, following the 1999 directive. Capital gains rules vary widely. Germany applies zero CGT after a 12-month holding period on physical bullion, making it among the most favourable regimes globally. France imposes a flat 11% wealth tax on transactions or a 36.2% capital gains tax. Italy taxes at 26%.
Reporting and AML
The trend across all three jurisdictions is toward stricter reporting. The US Form 8300 covers cash transactions over $10,000. The EU's 6th AML Directive lowered the cash threshold for precious metals dealers. The UK requires dealer reporting on transactions above £10,000. Privacy in gold transactions is increasingly limited above retail amounts.
Structuring matters
For larger positions, the structure can save more than the price moves. Holding through a Roth IRA, a UK SIPP with permitted gold ETFs, or a German private holding above the 12-month threshold can shift after-tax returns by hundreds of basis points annually.
Takeaway: The tax wrapper is part of the investment thesis. Ignoring it is a quiet way to lose returns that no market move can recover.
Reader Letters
The mailroom is empty.Be the first to write in.